More about The Fall

from the chapter “The Fall (continued)” in GOD IS LOVE

After the serpent gives his sales pitch to Eve, she goes in for a snack. “The woman saw that the tree was good for food, pleasing to the eyes, and desirable for gaining wisdom. So she took some of its fruit and ate it; and she also gave some to her husband, who was with her, and he ate it” (Gen 3:6). Adam and Eve ate the fruit that was explicitly forbidden because, unbeknownst to them, it came with knowing the conditions of good and evil. But did they die upon its consumption, as God had warned? Nope, not at that moment, but what does happen next is the whole sacred wisdom of the story. Unfortunately, this pivotal theological wisdom gets completely skipped over in the teacher’s/preacher’s/reader’s hurry to get to the wrong lesson: “See they were disobedient, and God got mad because they did something wrong. God kicked them out and punished every other human being who would ever live.”

 The deed was done in verse 6, and verse 7 delivers the real repercussions. It all happens in one verse—roughly 27 words. “Then the eyes of both of them were open, and they realized that they were naked; so they sewed fig leaves together and made loincloths for themselves” (Gen 3:7). They obtained the knowledge of good and evil, and the very first thing that happened was turning their backs on their ideal, natural state. They understood who they were as evil or wrong. No wonder GOD/LOVE did not want them to have this knowledge. Before they ate the fruit, they were who God created them to be and “felt no shame” (Gen 2:25). They were who they were and perfectly content. But upon knowing good and evil, they immediately understand who they are as evil and cover themselves. It is crystal clear that they do not see what they did as evil but who they are as evil. Their “nakedness,” their natural state as created by God, is cited as the problem, not their actions. They hide themselves, not the “apple core.” They are the same creations of God that they were two verses ago, but now, knowing the conditions of good and evil, they are ashamed of who they are and withdraw.

 Notice that this fundamental change happens before God even strolls onto the scene, which God will literally do in a few verses. Look how things go south for humanity without God lifting a finger. They did not eat the fruit and become like God in such a way that God would perceive them as a threat to God’s own divinity. The fruit did not transform them into omnipotent divine beings that God must now punish and evict to protect God’s own sovereignty. They ate the fruit that gave them this god-like power and the first thing they did was feel shame, make loincloths, and run off into the woods to hide. I do not think God was feeling overly threatened by them “becoming like” [Him]. They became “like God” by picking up the knowledge of good and evil like a toddler becomes “like a carpenter” by picking up an automatic nail gun. Humanity now has a god-like power that is way beyond its capacity to wield responsibly. It will separate them from God and from who they were created to be by bringing division and hatred to creation.

 Upon eating the fruit, and upon knowing the conditions of good and evil, humanity is instantaneously and intrinsically transformed into something God did not intend. There is cause and effect here. Like fire to burning, like gravity to falling, like water to wetness. A cause has produced an effect, and the effect is intrinsic to the action. It is as if they touched fire, and the fire burned them. The transformation happens without God’s presence or any hands-on punishment. God is not even on the scene, and God does not then appear with some half-related punishment. God did not enter stage right and say, “You ate the fruit! You’ve been disobedient! Get out!” This is not a situation of a kid who steals a cookie from a cookie jar, gets discovered by the parent, and then gets a spanking. This is a kid who steals a cookie from a cookie jar and immediately starts suffocating from anaphylactic shock. They ate the fruit, and it changed them, and the change had nothing to do with punishment from God.

 Herein lies the story’s sacred wisdom, and it is not about Adam and Eve being evicted from Eden for disobedience. Despite that being the long-held moral of the story, Adam and Eve’s punishments and eviction from the garden are literally and literarily denouement and resolution, literal and literary afterthought to the sacred wisdom of the story. The “Fall” was an inherent consequence of knowing the conditions of good and evil. Humanity “fell” even before God was a character in this part of the story. However, GOD/LOVE will soon arrive to clean up our mess.

Tools for Spiritual Journeys