More about Is-ness

from the chapter “Our Is-ness” in GOD IS LOVE

Several times in previous chapters I have used the term Is-ness in reference to either God’s essence or humanity’s, whatever “essence” means. It is a silly-sounding term, but I chose it with intention. Is-ness refers to the very identity of something, the seat of a thing or being’s essence or existence. It is the “who-ness” of who someone is. In the case of a person, it is their Is-ness that was created in, and is now called to become, or be, the image of God.

One might be tempted to say, “Oh, you are speaking of the soul! You are referring to the seat of our true self, the soul that resides within our body, inside the flesh!” No, I am not. The body/soul paradigm of self-understanding is so unhelpful for the daily journey of faith and has been so easily weaponized against God’s good creation through time that it has caused far more damage than goodness in Christian history writ large and in the lives of individual Christians.

This paradigm’s ability to cause damage takes many shapes. One example is, “My soul has been saved, so how my body operates in this world is largely inconsequential.” Or “My soul has been saved, so gimme, gimme, gimme what I want in the here and now and screw everybody else. Build that wall!” Or “My soul is what is important, so I think I should torture, maim, and inflict pain on my evil body.” Or “Anything that makes the body feel good (sex, the taste of strawberries, the taste of strawberries while having sex) lends itself to the destructive power that good/evil thinking wreaks in human life. Much more on that in chapters to come.

It is interesting to note that the body/soul construct was basically a Greek philosophical understanding fully imported into the Christian movement after several centuries. As an ancient Hebrew, Jesus Himself would have had no view of human persons as split into souls and bodies. Ancient Hebrews saw a person’s totality within their flesh. That’s why the idea of bodily resurrection was a big and controversial idea in the religious circles of Jesus’s day and age, and how the belief in bodily resurrection found its way into Christianity. Two early creeds, creeds still relied upon in Christian ritual and theology, profess this central belief. The “Apostle’s Creed” states belief in “the resurrection of the body”; the “Nicene Creed,” recited at every Catholic Sunday Mass, asserts, “I look forward to the resurrection of the dead and the life of the world to come.”

Since the ancient Hebrews and the earliest followers of Christ did not understand a person as a combination of body and soul, if there was to be something after death, that something necessitated the resurrection of the body. When the earliest followers of Christ started to be martyred, and their bodies weren’t being resurrected yet, the idea of a soul was imported as a stop-gap measure to fill the problematic space until bodily resurrection occurred. It’s remarkable to think that much of contemporary Christianity’s entire raison d’être, the motivation to save individualized, invisible souls, is a concept that would have been completely unintelligible to Jesus Himself, and completely absent from the early Christian movement.

 One of the most problematic aspects of contemporary Christianity’s emphasis on the soul is that it is often understood as our “ghost self”—an individualized, invisible version of a human being. It is often seen as the important “good” us while the body is the unimportant “bad” us. Please see all the issues with this listed above. Yet understood this way, our invisible souls are subject to the same whims and sins as our bodies. We can selfishly want the salvation of our invisible soul just as our body selfishly wants a taco or a Mercedes Benz. An invisible self carries largely the same baggage as our visible one.

Instead of seeing each of us as body and soul, we need to see a person’s Is-ness as the seat of their truest identity, their truest self. It is not the individualized, invisible, more important ghost version of your individualized, visible, less important (maybe even evil!) physical self. Your Is-ness makes you the unique person you are, the unique image of GOD/LOVE that GOD/LOVE made you to be. Don’t ponder soul, spirit, or body language. Just think about the totality of the Is-ness that makes you you. But most importantly, do not think of it as something that gives love or traffics in love or does love (or selfishly desires its own salvation or a Mercedes Benz); it is the unique image of GOD/LOVE that is you and is capable of being what it was created to be—love/agape.

Tools for Spiritual Journeys